Theme Layout

Boxed or Wide or Framed

Theme Translation

Display Featured Slider

Featured Slider Styles

Display Grid Slider

No

Grid Slider Styles

Display Trending Posts

No

Display Author Bio

No

Display Instagram Footer

Dark or Light Style

766464686786977
ABS-CBN Blog Giveaway Cinemalaya Film Festival Dulaang UP Entertainment Featured forbidden broadway four sisters and a wedding fox fr joaquin bernas fringe frozen furious 7 fyi galema: anak ni zuma game of thrones Games and Technology gandang gabi vice gangnam style gawad urian gerald anderson giordano glee Globe GCASH Globe Telecom gloc-9 gloria arroyo GMA gma records god of carnage gods of egypt godzilla golden globe awards got to believe gotham grab taxi grammy awards grease green lantern hanggang ngayon hannibal happy feet harry potter harvey milk headshot clinic headshot clinic unite health/well-being heather morris hennessy artistry halo heroes heroes reborn homophobia horoscope hugot hultman hustisya i love you thank you ian felix alquiros ian somerhalder Icey ifestyle iFlix ilustrado ima castro imollo in the scene ina kapatid anak indio inigo pascual iñigo pascual instagram interviews interxn into the woods ios iphone iron pinoy magazine isdaan floating restaurant it takes a man and a woman it's showtime j.co donuts jack and the beanstalk jack ryan: shadow recruit james reid jamey rodemeyer janice de belen jason balabal jc de vera jekyll and hyde jerico redrico jerome ponce jesse robredo jessica sanchez jessica sojo jessie j jm de guzman joanna ampil joe: a filipino rock'sical john ford coley john lloyd cruz john spainhour jollibee jomai cascante jonas gruet jonathan yabut jordan ladra josh delos santos joyce ramirez juan dela cruz juana c. the movie juanvote julia montes julie andrews julie anne san jose jupiter ascending just one summer just the way you are justin bieber kahit puso'y masugatan kailangan ko'y ikaw karylle kathryn bernardo katrina halili kc concepcion kean cipriano keanu reeves kelly hu kevin posadas kevin vitug khalil ramos kid kulafu kidlat kids acts philippines kierwin larena kim chiu kimmy dora kit thompson know your Llimits then ignore them kuh ledesma kung fu divas la cocina de tita moning la familia peratedes la partida lady gaga lance armstrong lani misalucha laura fygi lea salonga leading ladies lee grane legal/labor leighton meester leo valdez leonardo dicaprio les miserables lexi liam hemsworth Lifestyle and Travel limon underwear line little champ lobo london 2012 olympics lorenz martinez love love of siam lovi poe lucifer lucy luigi d'avola lumayo ka nga sa akin lumia lumia 1020 lumia 6030 lupin the third lytro camera maalaala mo kaya madonna magic mike magic mike xxl maja salvador maleficent malese jow mamma mia manila restop manny pacquiao manny pangilinan maria la del bario marian rivera maricel soriano marife necesito marife necessito mario maurer mark luz mark zuckerberg markki stroem martin del rosario martin nievera marvel mason lockwood mateo gudicelli matteo guidicelli maxie the musical megan young members of the church of god international meme mentos mercedes cabral metro manila mga mumunting lihim michael christian martinez michael trevino michelle obama microsoft miko raval minority report miriam quiambao miss saigon Miss Universe miss world mmff mmff new wave category mo twister mon tulfo monique wilson mooloolabas slippers moon of desire movie review mr gay world philippines mr metro top model ms earth ms earth usa mtrcb mtv video music awards mulan muling buksan ang puso mundo man ay magunaw music my husband's lover my little bossings mymusicstoreph myrtle sarrosa nandito ako nang dahil sa pag-ibig national geographic channel nba finals neil armstrong nereku big bag project Netflix news next fall nfl 2013 nike nikki gil no way to treat a lady noah nobu manila nokia nokia asha 503 nokia x nokia xl nora aunor nothing compares to you nuel naval nuffnang nymphomaniac nyphomaniac oishi oj mariano on the job one more chance one more try online shopping opera belles oprah winfrey oscars otso outbox media pacquiao vs bradley pacquiao vs marquez pageants pagpag pagpag syam na buhay pahiram ng isang umaga panday 2 paolo onesa para sa hopeless romantic party pilipinas patrick libao paul walker paulo avelino pbb pdaf penshoppe people personal peta peter pan pets pgt results philippine opera company philippine stagers foundation philippine volcanoes philippineparadisepages.com philippines phoebe Tonkin photography phuket pilipinas got talent pinky marquez pinocchio pinoy big brother pinoy big brother teen edition pinoy box-office pinoy hoops piolo pascual plagiarism pldt pokwang Politics and Religion posted by jae praybeyt benjamin pridyider primo psy puss in boots pwd pyra and babaeng apoy qcinema rabbit hole rachelle ann go rak of aegis raniel rasuelo ratings reality entertainment reb atadero red turnip theater regal films rent repertory philippines resorts world manila review rhian ramos rhodora x richard poon ricky pempengco rico blanco ricotitos risa hontiveros rob shneider robinsons galleria robocop rodgers and hammerstein's cinderella rogue rpg metanoia rtl cbs entertainment rurouni kenshin russ williams russia sa ngalan ng ina sa north diversion road sa wakas sabel sag awards salvi ang pagpadayon sam ajdani sam concepcion samsung sarah geronimo sarong banggi sayaw ng dalawang kaliwang paa scarlett johansson scrooge sean penn sebastian castro series finale shaina magdayao shan cruz rivera sharon cuneta she's dating the gangster she's the one sherwin abuel shia labeouf si agimat si enteng kabisote at ako signs sinag maynila sineng pambansa national film festival sisterakas skylight films skype slater young sleepy hollow slumber party sm sm pampanga shooting sm seaside city cebu smart c+ Smart Communications smart infinity smdc smokin' pig legendary rib joint snapshots sofitel solaire resort and casino sony sophia abella sound of music spice girls Sponsored Post sports spotify spring film festival stages star awards 2012 star cinema star movies star wars star world star-crossed Starbucks starting over again steve jobs stomp suddenly it's magic suits summer station id Sun Cellular sundown music festival super bowl supergirl supot survivor philippines t2 talk back and you're dead Tandem tanghalang pilipino taylor kinnet teatro porvenir tehankee telebabad terminator genisys thailand that awkward moment the adventurer: the curse of the midas box the amazing race philippines the amazing spider-man the animals the apprentice asia the blacklist the bluebird of happiness the buzz the corruption of melba the curious case of benjamin button the dans the dark knight rises the devil wears prada the duchess of malfi the flash the fray the gifted the graduate the healing the hero the hobbit: the battle of the five armies the hobbit: the desolation of smaug the hunger games the hungover games the interview the joy luck club the king and the diva the kitchen musical the legal wife the lion king the little prince the little racals the love affair the love yourself project the maneuvers the mega and the songwriter the mistress the paperboy the perks of being a wallflower the phantom of the opera the producers the reunion the revenant the rock the seagull the secret circle the sound of music the strangers the thank you girls the trial the vampire diaries the walking dead the wizard of oz the woman in black theater they're playing our song things you read think before you click this guy's in love with you mare thor: the dark world thy womb tikoy aguiluz tiktik tito sotto titus andronicus tom cruise tom daley tom rodriguez toni gonzaga torrent trailer transit travel trg trumpets tuhog tv5 twilight twitter tyler lockwood typhoon yolanda uaap cheerdance competition united nations world food programme unitel uno magazine unofficially yours up cinema up repertory ust artistang artlets valiente vhong navarro viber vic sotto vice ganda vice gov mark leviste villa quintana vilma santos vin abrenica walang forever walang kukurap walang sugat wentworth miller whistleblower whitney houston wicked willie revillame wns wonder twins world of warcraft wrangler x-men xian lim you're a good man charlie brown you're my boss zac efron zachary quinto zalora zanzoe marudo

Labor Woes and the NLRC -part 4-



Part 4:


The Verdict (transcript)

Republic of the Philippines
Department of Labor and Employment
NATIONAL LABOR RELATIONS COMMISSION
National Capital Region Arbitration Branch Quezon City

JOHN DALE B. BACAR, ET AL.,
Complainants,
NLRC CASE NO. NCR-00-06-05501-07

-versus-

GAMEPAL INTERNATIONAL
CORPORATION, ET AL.,
Respondents,

x----------------------------------------x

RICHELLE N. RAMAS,
ET AL.,
Complainants,
NLRC CASE NO. NCR-00-06-05718-07

-versus-

GAMEPAL INCORPORATED/
Mr. ERIC SMITH, ET AL.,
Respondents,

x----------------------------------------x

DECISION

Submitted for resolution is a consolidated case of money claims for unpaid salaries or wages, 13th month pays, separation pays, allowances, for an award of damages filed be the above-indicated complainants on various dates against the aforecited respondents.

Complainants Bacar, Reyes and Feliciano were all managerial employees while Emmanuel Feliciano worked as Quality Monitor. As such, they continuously performed their jobs as designated until April 30, 2007 when complainants as well as other employees received a memo issued by the Board informing the former of the corporation’s “temporary closure”. It turned out however, to be a permanent or total closure. Hence, firmly believing that complainants are entitled to their separation pays and other unpaid salaries, they filed the instant complaint with this forum.

Complainants strongly contend the closure effected by respondents was defective and runs contrary to law because of the following reasons: 1. There was no legal basis for such total closure. The financial statements of the company accountant showed that even at 50% depreciation, the remaining assets are still sufficient to cover the obligations which the company incurred as well as the severance pay of all employees; 2. The only reason why it was not done was because of the refusal of the remaining board members in the country (respondents Michelle Marin and Kristine Rodrigo) to cooperate with Daisy Bongais who is also a member of the Board to prepare the board resolution stating the liquidation of said assets; 3. Contrary to Marin’s defense that she acted in good faith, her vehement refusal to help out in the liquidation of the company’s assets considering that she is a corporate officer, is a manifestation of bad faith; and 4. Respondents did not comply with the mandatory notice requirement which is the sending of a simultaneous notice to the employees and to the DOLE at least 30 days before the intended closure.

The purpose of the notice requirement is for the employees to be able to seek substitute employment and for the DOLE to ascertain whether such closure is bona fide or not. Hence, complainants pray for the granting of all the reliefs which they seek to recover in their position papers.

On the other hand, respondent Marin argues that the complaint with respect to her should be dismissed due to the following reasons. 1. She is only holding the position of Administrative Manager, as such she was just a mere employee of respondent corporation and has no hand on the complaint filed by the complainants; 2. The liabilities and other money claims should be borne by the corporation and not its officers or stockholders because a corporation has a personality separate and distinct from the stockholders; and 3. Respondent corporation has already ceased totally its operations due to serious financial reverses as evidenced with the leaving of all corporate officers who are foreigners out of the country in April 2007, so she and the remaining officers should not be made liable to pay complainants’’ separation pays and other accountabilities of the corporation. Hence, respondent prays for the dismissal of the instant complaint for lack of merit.

The issues to be resolved in the instant case are the following:
1. Whether or not the closure of the respondent corporation’s business was bona fide or valid; and
2. Whether or not complaints are entitled to the money claims which they seek to recover.
There is no doubt that under Article 283 of the Labor Code, total or complete closure of a business due to serious financial reverses is one of the authorized causes for the termination of the employment of the affected employees and the business establishment is not obliged to pay the separation pays of the affected employees.

Nevertheless, for such closure to be legal or valid, it must comply with the mandatory requirement of sending simultaneous notices to both the affected employees and the nearest Department of labor and Employment which has the jurisdiction over the working place of the business establishment concerned, at least 30 days before the intended closure.

In the instant case, this forum finds no iota of evidence of compliance to the aforesaid requirements. The notice to the employees is intended to forewarn them of the impending closure in order that they could seek substitute employments and for the DOLE to investigate whether the closure is bona fide or was just concocted to circumvent the law and evade existing legitimate obligation to the affected employees. Hence, the total closure effected by the above indicated respondents is defective and was not bona fide as it was intended to circumvent the statutory law. The corporate officers impleaded are therefore obligated to pay the respective separation pays of herein complaint.

Besides, a close perusal of the affirmative allegation of both party-litigants shows that respondents did not refute or impugn the allegation or complainants as attested by the company’s accountant, that the assets of the company are still more than sufficient to cover the existing obligation and payment of separation pays but respondents Marin and Rodrigo simply refused to open the corporation’s bank accounts to settle even just the severance pay of complainants. Such attitude of the aforecited officers was a manifestation of their bad faith which under the law makes them liable for the unsettled obligations towards the employees-complainants.

Moreover, this forum cannot acquiesce with the defense of respondent Marin that as an Administrative Officer or Manager, she is a mere employee of the corporation, who cannot therefore, be made liable to the claims of complainant. She is estopped to deny she is an employee and a member of the board at the same time.

Since respondents did not controvert the claims of complainants that they were not paid their remaining salaries, 13th month pay and allowance, all of these should be integrated in their respective severance or separation pays.

WHEREFORE, premises all considered, judgment is hereby rendered ordering respondents jointly and severally liable to pay the respective separation pays of complainants at one half (1/2) month pay for every year of service, plus their unpaid salaries, 13th month pay and allowances, to wit:

{Payment computation for John Dale Bacar, Jesus Joseph Reyes, Richelle Ramas-Feliciano and Emmanuel Feliciano}

SO ORDERED:
Quezon City, Philippines,
21 September 2007.
Signed.
FELIPE P. PATTI
Labor Arbiter



QuickEdit
Dale Bacar
0 Comments
Share This Post :

You Might Also Like

No comments:

Post a Comment